Of the things to make and sell that I checked on Etsy, macrame wall hangings list for the most by far, with a median asking price of $74, followed by canvas tote bags at $34.37 and pressed flower frames at $32. Soy wax melts and dog bandanas show the strongest sales signs, since Etsy showed a Bestseller badge on 21 of 41 wax melt listings and 19 of 41 dog bandanas, but both have a median price under $11, so you need to sell a lot of them.
I read the Etsy prices from real listings in November 2026, using the first page of results and leaving out the ads. They’re asking prices, not sold prices, and each search mixes sizes and sets, so treat them as a starting point and check current listings before you set your own. By “middle half” I mean the middle 50% of those prices, with the cheapest and most expensive quarter left out. For the yarn, fabric and cord crafts I left out listings for patterns, PDFs and kits, and for stickers and cards I left out digital files, so the numbers are for finished pieces.
I didn’t make any of these crafts myself, so the supplies come from each tutorial, and any cost numbers come from the source I name next to them. Lip scrub, bath bombs, rice heating pads and painted rocks are already in crafts to do when you’re bored, and wood projects have their own list in woodworking projects that sell, so they aren’t repeated here.
Time is the hidden cost: the two CandleScience tutorials give their own times, but the rest don’t, and I didn’t time anyone making these, so most crafts here have no hours listed. Time your first few pieces and add those hours to your price with the pricing formula for handmade items before you decide a craft is worth it.
Home and scent
Candles, wax melts and soap show up on almost every list of crafts to sell, and they had some of the most Bestseller badges I saw. They’re also the crafts with real rules attached, so read the rules for each one before you list anything.
Here are the supplies the candle and soap tutorials call for. Amazon prices change daily, so I’ve linked them without prices.
- Soy wax: a 10 lb bag of pure soy candle wax, or a 5 lb bag of soy wax if you’re only testing the idea
- Jars and tins: a 6 pack of 16 oz glass candle jars with lids or a 24 pack of 8 oz and 4 oz tins
- Wicks: a pack of 60 cotton wicks with tools (check the listing says the wicks have no metal core, because that decides whether the CPSC wick rules apply to you)
- Soap base: a 2 lb shea butter melt and pour base or a 2 lb ultra clear glycerin base
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. The Amazon links here pay me a small commission at no extra cost to you.
1. Soy candles

A soy candle is soy wax poured into a jar or tin around a wick, usually with fragrance oil. CandleScience’s how to make a soy candle says the project takes about 30 minutes and makes 2 candles. You’ll need soy wax, a container, a wick, fragrance oil, a pouring pitcher and a thermometer, with dye as an option.
The Consumer Product Safety Commission’s guidance for candle makers says metal-core wicks, and candles that use them, can’t have more than 0.06% lead in the metal core, and a metal-core wick needs a General Certificate of Compliance. Wicks without a metal core have no certification requirement, and candles that hold a hazardous substance need cautionary labeling. CPSC also lists ASTM F2058, a voluntary standard for candle fire-safety labels, by title only, and I couldn’t read what that standard asks for, so look it up yourself if you want to follow it.
Can you sell it? Yes, and it’s one of the safer bets of the 13.
- What it takes: soy wax, jars or tins, wicks and fragrance oil. Shopify’s guide says an eight-ounce jar candle “costs about $3 to $8 in materials and sells for $15 to $30”, which is its claim and not something I checked, and I didn’t price fragrance oil.
- Similar pieces sell for: 43 soy candles on Etsy ran from $3.45 to $74.99. Half were priced between $10.95 and $19.49, and the median was $12.99. Etsy showed a Bestseller badge on 16 of 43.
- My take: lots of Bestseller badges means shoppers buy candles, but the median is lower than Shopify’s $15 to $30, so a scent and a label people remember will matter more than the wax. Wicks with no metal core don’t need the certificate, so check that before you buy.
2. Soy wax melts

Wax melts are small pieces of scented wax that you warm in a wax warmer instead of burning with a wick. I didn’t look up a wax melt tutorial or price a set of supplies, so I can’t give you a supply list or a cost for these, only what they list for.
Can you sell it? Yes, but mostly as an add-on next to candles.
- What it takes: scented wax and molds (I didn’t research a tutorial or price these)
- Similar pieces sell for: 41 soy wax melt listings on Etsy ran from $1.75 to $34.99. Half were priced between $3 and $6.30, and the median was $4.95. Etsy showed a Bestseller badge on 21 of 41, the most of any craft I checked.
- My take: more than half the listings carrying the badge is a strong sign people buy these, but at around $5 each, Etsy’s fees take a bigger share of every sale. I’d sell them in bundles, or in the same shop as candles so one order holds several items.
3. Melt-and-pour soap

Melt-and-pour soap starts from a ready-made soap base that you melt, color, scent and pour into a mold. CandleScience’s melt and pour soap making for beginners is rated for beginners, and its search listing says it takes about 60 minutes and makes 3 bars. You’ll need soap base, a mold, soap colorant, fragrance, a spatula, a cutting board and an isopropyl alcohol spray.
What you say on the label decides which rules apply. In the FDA’s meaning, “soap” is only a product that’s mostly alkali salts of fatty acids, cleans because of them, and is labeled and sold only as soap, and that kind of true soap is regulated by CPSC, not the FDA. If the label says it moisturizes, smells nice or deodorizes, the FDA treats it as a cosmetic, and calling it “antibacterial” makes it a drug. Cosmetics must be safe and properly labeled, though the FDA doesn’t approve them before they’re sold (its fact sheet for homemade cosmetics and soap FAQ have more). I didn’t find FDA text that says whether a melt-and-pour bar counts as true soap, so keep your label claims simple, and if you sell it as a cosmetic, the label rules for lip scrub and bath bombs list what a cosmetic label needs.
Can you sell it? Yes, if you’re careful with what the label says.
- What it takes: soap base, a mold, colorant and fragrance. Shopify’s guide says a 4.5-ounce bar costs “about $3 to make”, citing Modern Soapmaking, which is its claim and not something I checked. I didn’t price molds, colorant or fragrance.
- Similar pieces sell for: 46 handmade soap bars on Etsy ran from $1.80 to $75. Half were priced between $6.21 and $25.19, and the median was $7.50. Etsy showed a Bestseller badge on 14 of 46.
- My take: a solid number of badges, but if a bar really costs about $3, a $7.50 price leaves little after fees and your time. Sets of bars or gift boxes sit better in that wide middle half.
Jewelry and accessories
4. Polymer clay earrings

Polymer clay earrings are shapes cut from oven-bake clay, baked hard and hung on earring hooks or posts. Craftsy Hacks’ polymer clay earrings guide lists polymer clay, cookie cutters, fine sandpaper, a rolling pin, jump rings, earring hooks or posts, pliers, E6000 glue and parchment paper. Kernowcraft has a second version that adds gemstone beads. Bake the clay the way its package says, and work in a well-ventilated room.
Jewelry made for children may come under separate CPSC rules, and I couldn’t open CPSC’s pages on children’s jewelry, so check them yourself before you sell earrings meant for kids.
Can you sell it? Yes, and it’s one of my top picks here.
- What it takes: polymer clay, cutters, earring hardware, pliers and an oven (I didn’t price the clay or hardware)
- Similar pieces sell for: 34 pairs of polymer clay earrings on Etsy ran from $7.20 to $49.95. Half were priced between $15 and $30, and the median was $23. Etsy showed a Bestseller badge on 10 of 34.
- My take: earrings are small and light, so they should be easy to mail, and a $23 median is higher than candles or soap, though I didn’t price clay or hardware. Your shapes and colors are what set you apart, so work out a style of your own before you list.
5. Resin coasters and keychains

Resin crafts are made by mixing two-part epoxy resin, pouring it into a silicone mold and letting it cure, sometimes with pressed flowers set inside. ArtResin has a tutorial on how to resin a coaster and another on how to make resin keychains. Between them they call for epoxy resin, a silicone mold, nitrile gloves, a mixing cup, a stir stick, a heat gun or torch, toothpicks and a dust cover, and the keychains add pressed flowers, a silicone alphabet mold and tweezers. Wear the gloves the tutorials list and work with good airflow, and measure the mix ratio carefully, because a wrong ratio can leave resin sticky.
Can you sell it? Coasters maybe, but I’d skip the keychains.
- What it takes: resin, silicone molds, gloves and mixing supplies (I didn’t price resin or molds)
- Similar pieces sell for: 51 resin coaster sets on Etsy ran from $2.25 to $78.20. Half were priced between $15 and $30, the median was $20.11, and Etsy showed a Bestseller badge on 4 of 51. 38 resin keychains ran from $4.51 to $35, with half between $7.49 and $14.48 and a median of $10.58, and Etsy showed a Bestseller badge on 3 of 38.
- My take: The Rich and Free says “everyone else is making the same resin keychains or scrunchies”, and with few badges and a median near $10, the keychain listings back that up. Coaster sets list for about twice as much, but they had few badges too, so I’d only try them with a look nobody else is selling.
6. Canvas tote bags
A sewn tote is a simple canvas bag with two handles, and I think it’s a good first sewing project to try. Heather Handmade’s tote bag sewing pattern uses 1/2 yard of canvas fabric and a sewing machine, and the pattern is free on the page (it also sells a $5 PDF version). Don’t print licensed characters or logos on anything you sell.
Can you sell it? Yes, if the fabric or the design makes it stand out.
- What it takes: 1/2 yard of canvas and a sewing machine (I didn’t price the canvas)
- Similar pieces sell for: 44 handmade canvas totes on Etsy had a low of $0.08 (likely a bulk or wholesale listing) and went up to $84. Half were priced between $26 and $44.99, and the median was $34.37. Etsy showed a Bestseller badge on 6 of 44.
- My take: the second-highest median here, but Shopify lists print-on-demand totes starting at $5.94 each, and those are the bags yours sit next to. A plain printed tote is hard to sell at $34, so I’d lean on fabric choice, linings and pockets to set yours apart.
7. Dog bandanas

A dog bandana is a triangle of fabric that ties around a dog’s neck or slides over its collar. All eight of the top-ranking pages I could read mention pet items, but I didn’t look up a bandana tutorial or price fabric, so there’s no supply list or cost here.
Can you sell it? Yes, it sells well but for a low price.
- What it takes: fabric and a way to sew or hem it (I didn’t research a tutorial or price these)
- Similar pieces sell for: 41 dog bandanas on Etsy ran from $4.54 to $25. Half were priced between $9.16 and $12, and the median was $10.88. Etsy showed a Bestseller badge on 19 of 41, second only to wax melts.
- My take: buyers clearly want these, but the middle half sits in a tight band around $10, so there isn’t much room to charge more. They’re small and light, so they should be easy to ship, and fabric scraps from other sewing might keep the cost down.
Yarn, cord and thread
8. Crochet dishcloths and beanies

Crochet shows up on nearly every list of crafts to sell, and dishcloths and beanies are the two pieces I checked on Etsy. Christa Co Design’s simple dishcloth is a free beginner pattern that uses 70 to 90 yards of worsted weight cotton yarn and a hook. Free patterns can limit selling the finished items, and I didn’t read this one’s terms, so check the designer’s terms before you sell anything made from a pattern.
Can you sell it? Beanies yes, but dishcloths list for very little.
- What it takes: cotton yarn (70 to 90 yards for one dishcloth) and a crochet hook (I didn’t price yarn, and I didn’t find a beanie pattern, so this is the dishcloth’s list)
- Similar pieces sell for: 29 crochet dishcloths on Etsy ran from $2.25 to $35. Half were priced between $4.50 and $13.60, the median was $7, and Etsy showed a Bestseller badge on 9 of 29. 45 crochet beanies ran from $11.89 to $50, with half between $22.99 and $34 and a median of $27, and Etsy showed a Bestseller badge on 4 of 45.
- My take: a $7 dishcloth doesn’t pay much for the time it takes to crochet, so I’d only sell them in sets. Beanies list for almost four times as much, though fewer carried the badge, so they’re the better use of your hours.
9. Macrame wall hangings

Macrame is cord tied in patterns of knots, and a wall hanging hangs from a wooden dowel or a branch. The Crafting Nook’s macrame basics for beginners covers the main knots, and the supplies are cotton macrame cord, a dowel or branch and scissors. The page says 4 mm to 7 mm cord is the most common and 4 to 5 mm is the easiest for beginners. Large hangings take a lot of cord, which eats into what you keep.
Can you sell it? Maybe, because the prices are high but the sales signs are weak.
- What it takes: cotton cord, a dowel or branch and scissors (I didn’t price cord, so I can’t say what a big piece costs to make)
- Similar pieces sell for: 39 macrame wall hangings on Etsy ran from $12.60 to $310.20. Half were priced between $35 and $122.50, and the median was $74, the highest of any craft I checked. Etsy showed a Bestseller badge on only 1 of 39.
- My take: the highest prices here come with the fewest badges, which suggests these don’t sell often at those prices. I’d start with small hangings that use less cord and see if they sell before buying cord for a big one.
10. Embroidery hoop art

Embroidery hoop art is a stitched design that stays in its wooden hoop and hangs on the wall as a finished piece. Cutesy Crafts’ how to embroider for beginners lists fabric, thread, needles, a hoop and supplies for tracing your design onto the fabric. Use your own designs, because paid patterns and kit patterns can forbid selling the finished piece, so read the terms before you sell one.
Can you sell it? Yes, especially with your own designs.
- What it takes: fabric, thread, needles and a hoop (I didn’t price these)
- Similar pieces sell for: 31 pieces of embroidery hoop art on Etsy ran from $2.93 to $66.23. Half were priced between $11.88 and $37.50, and the median was $23.15. Etsy showed a Bestseller badge on 11 of 31.
- My take: about a third of the listings carried the badge, and the median is close to polymer clay earrings, so this is a good one if you like to stitch. The supplies are small and the hoop doubles as the frame, but hand stitching is slow, so time your first piece before you price it.
Paper and flowers
11. Handmade greeting cards

Handmade cards are folded cardstock decorated by hand with lettering, layers or stamps. Tombow’s guide on how to start making handmade cards lists cardstock, a paper trimmer, a score board or ruler, markers or brush pens, adhesive and foam tape. Heavy decorations can make a card harder to mail, so keep them flat if you plan to ship.
Can you sell it? Yes, and the sales signs are strong.
- What it takes: cardstock, a trimmer, pens and adhesive (I didn’t price these)
- Similar pieces sell for: 49 handmade greeting cards on Etsy ran from $4.95 to $52.95. Half were priced between $6.58 and $19.99, and the median was $14. Etsy showed a Bestseller badge on 16 of 49.
- My take: a median of $14 is good money for a piece of folded cardstock, and the badge count is one of the highest here. Cards are also flat and easy to ship, and you can bundle them into sets.
12. Pressed flower frames

A pressed flower frame holds dried, flattened flowers arranged behind glass. I couldn’t load a pressed flower tutorial to use as a source, so I don’t have a supply list from one. The Rich and Free lists pressed flower phone grips first, saying they cost “cents” to make and sell for $12 to $20, which is its claim and not something I checked. If you set pressed flowers in resin instead, make sure they’re fully dry first.
Can you sell it? Yes, and it’s one of the better-priced crafts here.
- What it takes: pressed flowers and a frame (I didn’t research a tutorial or price frames)
- Similar pieces sell for: 46 pressed flower frames on Etsy ran from $13 to $109.35. Half were priced between $21.15 and $46.80, and the median was $32. Etsy showed a Bestseller badge on 8 of 46.
- My take: the third-highest median I found, and the lowest of the 46 listings I read was $13. I didn’t price frames, so price one before you decide what to charge, and keep in mind that glass should make shipping trickier.
13. Vinyl stickers

Print-and-cut stickers are designs printed on sticker paper and cut out by a cutting machine. The Etsy numbers are for vinyl stickers, while this tutorial uses printable sticker paper, so treat them as a rough guide. Jennifer Maker’s easy print and cut stickers uses a Cricut machine with Print Then Cut, a home inkjet printer and printable sticker paper. Don’t use other people’s art or fonts in stickers you sell unless you have a license for them.
Can you sell it? Skip it, unless you sell your own art in bulk.
- What it takes: a cutting machine, a printer and sticker paper (I didn’t price these)
- Similar pieces sell for: 40 vinyl sticker listings on Etsy ran from $0.09 (likely a per-piece bulk price) to $11.45. Half were priced between $0.24 and $3.99, and the median was $1.39. Etsy showed a Bestseller badge on 11 of 40.
- My take: people buy stickers, but most sell for pennies to a few dollars, and Etsy’s fees take a much bigger bite out of a $1.39 sale. A cutting machine is a real cost to win back at that price, so this only makes sense if you already draw and can sell packs or large orders.
Which things to make and sell are worth it
| Craft | Etsy median price | Bestseller badges | Worth selling? |
|---|---|---|---|
| Macrame wall hanging | $74 | 1 of 39 | Maybe, start small |
| Canvas tote bag | $34.37 | 6 of 44 | Yes, if it stands out |
| Pressed flower frame | $32 | 8 of 46 | Yes |
| Crochet beanie | $27 | 4 of 45 | Yes |
| Embroidery hoop art | $23.15 | 11 of 31 | Yes, with your own designs |
| Polymer clay earrings | $23 | 10 of 34 | Yes, a top pick |
| Resin coaster set | $20.11 | 4 of 51 | Maybe, with a fresh look |
| Handmade greeting card | $14 | 16 of 49 | Yes, a top pick |
| Soy candle | $12.99 | 16 of 43 | Yes |
| Dog bandana | $10.88 | 19 of 41 | Yes, at a low price |
| Resin keychain | $10.58 | 3 of 38 | Skip |
| Handmade soap bar | $7.50 | 14 of 46 | Yes, watch the label |
| Crochet dishcloth | $7 | 9 of 29 | Only in sets |
| Soy wax melts | $4.95 | 21 of 41 | Yes, in bundles |
| Vinyl sticker | $1.39 | 11 of 40 | Skip unless it’s your art |
Before you sell handmade crafts
- Check the rules for candles and soap: use wicks without a metal core, or keep the lead in a metal core under 0.06% and get the certificate CPSC asks for, and keep soap labels to what the FDA allows for the kind of product you’re selling.
- Sell your own designs: free and paid patterns can limit selling what you make from them, so check their terms, and other people’s art, fonts, characters and logos aren’t yours to sell.
- Count Etsy’s fees: cheap items lose a bigger share to fees, because part of what Etsy charges stays the same no matter the price, which is why wax melts, stickers and dishcloths do better in sets. The breakdown is in how much Etsy charges.
- Price in your time: the pricing formula for handmade items adds your materials, your hours and your fees, so you can see which crafts pay you and which ones only cover their supplies.
If you’re opening a shop for the first time, the step-by-step guide to selling on Etsy covers what you need to get set up. For crafts made from found materials, try these license plate craft ideas or driftwood craft ideas.
Happy crafting, and good luck with your first sale!
Leave a Reply